Pencil Coils For a 12Valve???
I'm looking to use a coil on plug ignition system for my 12 valve V6, but finding decent, well priced coils is a bit of a challenge.
AEM's shorter http://www.aemelectronics.com/ignition- ... -coils-20/ coils look to be a good fit, but they say they "Must be used with CDI ignition module". Now I don't want to use a CDI system, especially AEM's 1 as:
A: It doesn't have a good reputation on AEM's own forum, though that was an older version (apparently).
B: They don't make a 6 cylinder version and the thought of having to pay for the expensive 8 cylinder 1 to leave a quarter of it unused puts me off even more.
Can anybody name well priced, reliable individual coils that fit in the spark plug tubes of the 12V and have very little protruding out (I don't want much )???
Obviously being able to get the appropriate plugs is essential, too.
*Edit: You can use AEM's Twin Fire CDI in a waste spark set up*
AEM's shorter http://www.aemelectronics.com/ignition- ... -coils-20/ coils look to be a good fit, but they say they "Must be used with CDI ignition module". Now I don't want to use a CDI system, especially AEM's 1 as:
A: It doesn't have a good reputation on AEM's own forum, though that was an older version (apparently).
B: They don't make a 6 cylinder version and the thought of having to pay for the expensive 8 cylinder 1 to leave a quarter of it unused puts me off even more.
Can anybody name well priced, reliable individual coils that fit in the spark plug tubes of the 12V and have very little protruding out (I don't want much )???
Obviously being able to get the appropriate plugs is essential, too.
*Edit: You can use AEM's Twin Fire CDI in a waste spark set up*
Last edited by Duk on Wed Nov 30, 2011 6:44 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Re: Pencil Coils For a 12Valve???
have you given up on the rb30 ecu idea?
not much help as i dont know what coils these are, but it has been done successfully.
not much help as i dont know what coils these are, but it has been done successfully.
- Attachments
-
- testfit_intake_cops.jpg (66.48 KiB) Viewed 8809 times
79 GTV (sr20) 83 GTV (TS) 85 GTV, 76 GT, 84 GTV6, 91 164, 88 75 TS & 89 75 TS
Re: Pencil Coils For a 12Valve???
I actually recon I could make distributorless ignition work with the RB30ecu (would require directing of the ignition signal via hall effect sensors switching solid state relays to 3 different channels.), but there are 3 major limitations with the old Nissan ecu idea that I think would compromise the whole shooting match. So when a well priced Adaptronic E420c popped up on another forum, I pounced (Hmmmmmmm, a pouncing duck )BradGTV wrote:have you given up on the rb30 ecu idea?
- Giuliettaevo2
- Verde
- Posts: 790
- Joined: Sun May 08, 2005 11:56 pm
- Location: Netherlands
Re: Pencil Coils For a 12Valve???
Kinda looks like VW/Audi items... these are quite narrow and the length is not too bad either.
Drive it like you stole it...
-
- Silver
- Posts: 39
- Joined: Tue Mar 09, 2010 12:12 pm
Re: Pencil Coils For a 12Valve???
You'll need some form of distributorless triggering of the coils. That would boil down to some form of ECU rather quickly, unless you want to fabricate your own analogue electronics, or mechanical advance system with 6 contact points.
My suggestion would be to go to your local car wreck yard and get a bunch of different coils there to find some that fit well in your engine. Then get 6 of the best fitting ones, get wiring loom material for that and wire it up to something like a megasquirt or megaspark or equivalent ignition computer. Either that, or go full EFI and use a computer for both.
My suggestion would be to go to your local car wreck yard and get a bunch of different coils there to find some that fit well in your engine. Then get 6 of the best fitting ones, get wiring loom material for that and wire it up to something like a megasquirt or megaspark or equivalent ignition computer. Either that, or go full EFI and use a computer for both.
Re: Pencil Coils For a 12Valve???
WhizzMan wrote:You'll need some form of distributorless triggering of the coils. That would boil down to some form of ECU rather quickly, unless you want to fabricate your own analogue electronics, or mechanical advance system with 6 contact points.
My suggestion would be to go to your local car wreck yard and get a bunch of different coils there to find some that fit well in your engine. Then get 6 of the best fitting ones, get wiring loom material for that and wire it up to something like a megasquirt or megaspark or equivalent ignition computer. Either that, or go full EFI and use a computer for both.
She's right, WizzMan, the Adaptronic E420c is where it's at for me.
Having accurate dimensions is more financially friendly than buying a bunch of coils.
Some stuff I saw on a Megasquirt forum hinted that some model Yamaha R6 coils are transistor switched style coils. Getting the Denso brand plugs and pins is straight forward as they are apparently the same as the AEM coils I linked above.
Cheers for the link, GT.
Re: Pencil Coils For a 12Valve???
Nice Duk, the E420c is awesome.
It transformed my car thats for sure.
It transformed my car thats for sure.
Selling 1985 GTV6.
Ecu and injectors, lightened.....plays music.
Re: Pencil Coils For a 12Valve???
Yep. I've got 1 in my twin charged Toyota MR2 and while I'm still basically running around on a base map, I'm really happy with it (it still runs very rich on boost, tho)
The Alfa will go together without the supercharger 1st, but hopefully with extractors and distributorless ignition. A decent (mostly road for fuel, but dyno for ignition timing) tune so I know where I'm at.
Then the SC will then go on and the on boost tuning will happen.
The Alfa will go together without the supercharger 1st, but hopefully with extractors and distributorless ignition. A decent (mostly road for fuel, but dyno for ignition timing) tune so I know where I'm at.
Then the SC will then go on and the on boost tuning will happen.
Re: Pencil Coils For a 12Valve???
I thought I'd add that Yamaha R6 coils fit quite nicely down the spark plug tubes in the 12 valve. The length is perfect but there is a difference in the diameter of the top of the coil (27mm) and the spark plug tube (33mm), so bushes would need to be made so that the coils locate properly at the top and seal well.
Something to note about bike coils is that lots of them use CDI (Capacitive Discharge Ignition) and these coils won't last with conventional transistor switched ignition systems. From what I found on the 'net, 2006 onwards R6's (and probably R1's) use transistor ignition systems (emissions based stuff, apparently CDI systems struggle to ignite lean mixtures). I scored 8 of ebay for about $80US.
A huge plus is being able to buy the plugs and pins (Denso) brand new for a good price.
Something to note about bike coils is that lots of them use CDI (Capacitive Discharge Ignition) and these coils won't last with conventional transistor switched ignition systems. From what I found on the 'net, 2006 onwards R6's (and probably R1's) use transistor ignition systems (emissions based stuff, apparently CDI systems struggle to ignite lean mixtures). I scored 8 of ebay for about $80US.
A huge plus is being able to buy the plugs and pins (Denso) brand new for a good price.
- Attachments
-
- Coil2.jpg (109.18 KiB) Viewed 8564 times
-
- Coil1.jpg (120.73 KiB) Viewed 8564 times